← All posts
Progress updates · 4 min read

$328 up in my first month

I've sold a few bear call spreads and the account is now at $1,328, a $328 gain from my $1,000 starting balance, so far in my first month of The Trading Quest. I'm happy with the start, but the risk has been too high, even though it has felt worth taking.

$328 up in my first month

There is finally some trading progress to write about. After starting The Trading Quest with a plan for credit spreads, I have now sold a few bear call spreads and I am up $328 so far in my first month. It is a good start, and I am pleased to have something more concrete to share than the setups I was thinking about before placing the first trades.

The risk has been too high, though. It has felt worth taking to me, but I want that included in the update alongside the profit. Otherwise, it would be easy to read the result and come away with a very different impression of how aggressively I have been trading.

From planning credit spreads to placing trades

In my Day 1 update, I was preparing for my first SPX credit spread and considering both bull put spreads and bear call spreads. There was no trade to report yet. I was looking at the approach I wanted to take and how much risk I was willing to accept.

Since then, I have sold a few bear call spreads. The basic structure is to sell a call and buy another call at a higher strike with the same expiration. The spread brings in a net credit, and its maximum potential profit is that credit before costs. At expiration, the most favorable outcome is for the underlying to finish below the short call strike. The Options Industry Council has a fuller explanation of the structure and its risks.

That gives some context for the trades behind this update. The money received when opening a spread is not automatically money earned, because there is still a position to manage. What I am reporting here is that I am now up $328 overall, rather than simply adding up the premiums collected.

$328 is a meaningful start

The account started with $1,000 and is now at $1,328, a gain of $328. That is a meaningful change for an account this size. It is enough to make this first update feel quite different from the planning post. I am happy with that result, and I do not need to turn it into a prediction about the rest of the year for it to matter.

There have only been a few trades so far. That is a small amount of experience to judge a strategy from, especially when the positions carry a lot of risk relative to the account. I can report a positive start without treating the first month's progress as an established monthly return.

The month is also still underway. This is where I stand now, rather than a final month-end result or a target that the next month has to match. I want these updates to reflect the account as it develops, including the parts that are less comfortable to write about.

The risk has been too high

I was already talking about aggressive risk in the first post. The plan I described there involved potentially risking around $500 to collect roughly $40 to $60 in premium. Those were planning figures, not a breakdown of the trades in this update, but they show the kind of approach I was considering from the beginning.

My assessment now is that the risk I have taken has been too high. A spread can have a defined maximum loss and still be a large position for the account holding it. Knowing the loss is capped does not make that loss small, particularly when the account itself is small.

At the same time, taking that risk has felt worth it to me. I am pleased with the progress, and that is part of why I have accepted the risk. The difficulty is judging the decision fairly while looking at a positive result. A profitable outcome can make a trade feel more reasonable afterwards without changing what was at stake when it was opened.

A loss larger than the profit built up so far could erase that progress in one trade. That possibility belongs in the update just as much as the gain does. The fact that I am up $328 does not resolve the question of whether the position sizes are sensible.

What I need to judge alongside the profit

For the next trades, the useful comparison is between the amount I could lose, the credit available, and the size of the account. The dollar profit alone cannot tell me whether I am making better decisions. I also need to consider how much of the account a losing trade could take away and whether I would still accept that exposure without the confidence of a positive start.

When I come back to this update later, I want to be able to see what I thought about the risk while the account was up. It would be less useful to leave that concern out now and only discuss it after a loss. I am pleased with the start, and the risk has felt worth taking, but I am still questioning how much of the account I have been willing to put behind these trades.

Keep reading

More from the quest